The first advance estimate of economic activities in FY2021 (April 2020 to March 2021) released by Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation shows that the Indian economy will likely contract by 7.7% in FY2021. GVA (at basic prices) contraction is expected to be 7.2%. This is due to the severe economic disruptions— supplies as well as demand shocks— caused by the pandemic and the ensuing lockdowns that started from March 25 and was relaxed in a phased manner since June. The Indian economy had been slowing down even before the pandemic, especially since FY2017, when the economy grew by 8.3%.
The only saving grace is agricultural sector, which is expected to grow by 3.4% on the back of favorable monsoon and the output surge as labor reverse migrated to villages after the lockdowns. All other sectors are expected to contract. Industry sector, which accounts for about 30% of the economy, as a whole will likely contract by 9.6%. The pandemic accelerated its slowdown as it was already losing steam, especially since FY2017. For the 2011-12 national accounts data, industrial sector growth peaked at 9.6% in FY2016. Within the industry sector, manufacturing activities have slowed down the most. It barely grew last fiscal (0.03%). In FY2021, it is expected to contract by 9.4%. Mining & quarrying activities are expected to contract by 12.4% and construction by 8.8%. However, electricity, gas, water supply and other utilities are expected to post a 2.7% growth.
Services sector, which accounts for about 54% of the economy, is expected to contract by 8.8%, with the largest contraction in trade, hotels, transport and communications activities (-21.4%). These were severely affected during the lockdowns and continue to be partially affected even after relaxation of lockdowns. Financial services were not that affected compared to other activities (-0.8% growth). The slowdown in public spending is reflected in 3.7% contraction in public administration, defense and other services.
On the expenditure side, consumption and investment are expected to contract sharply, but net exports are expected to improve largely because of slower deceleration of exports compared to imports. While public consumption is expected to grow by 5.8%, private consumption is expected to contract by 9.5%. Similarly, gross fixed capital formation is expected to contract by 14.5%, and change in stocks by 4.3%, indicating that the surge in pent-up demand has not been strong enough yet to clear and restock inventories. Exports and imports are expected to contract by 8.3% and 20.5%, respectively.
The current forecast is based on the expectation of pickup in economic activities in the second half of FY2021. The economy contracted 23.9% and 7.5% in the first and second quarters, respectively. As expected, the most severe contraction was in services sector.
Overall, the already slowing economy is expected to slowdown even faster due to the lockdowns and the lingering effect of the pandemic. Specifically, the slowdown in industrial sector since FY2017 is concerning. This is even more concerning in the case of manufacturing activities, which account for about 17% of the economy (one percentage point higher than the agriculture sector). This slowdown is actually reflected as a drop in capital formation, which contracted by 2% in FY2020 and is expected to further contract by 15.3% in FY2021. Note that first advanced estimate of GDP is based on data available (and its extrapolation) up to the first six to eight months of the fiscal year.
Historically, FY2021 is going to be the worst fiscal year in terms of GDP growth (2011-12 constant prices series starting from FY1952). Previously, the economy contracted five times: FY1958 (-0.4%), FY1966 (-2.6%), FY1967 (-0.1%), FY1973 (-0.6%), and FY1980 (-5.2%).
The FY2022 central budget will focus on economic recovery and vaccine rollout. All eyes will be on how the government manages to increase public capital investment as well as secure financing for vaccine and its eventual coordinate, distribution and administration right up to the last mile. Gradual normalization of economic activities, income earnings and government’s fiscal support in terms of social security payments will prop up consumption.
The expected slow pace of vaccine rollout in the initial phase and myriad challenges in its distribution and eventual administration might drag growth prospects, especially that of travel and tourism sector, in addition to the impending financial and fiscal sector stresses, which are expected to hit private as well as public investment.
A sharp recovery in FY2022’s GDP growth inherently will have a large base effect component. The pace of the recovery in the following years may not be that fast without a sharp pick up in capital spending/investment (watch out for the additional NIP investment).
In its January 2020 GEP, the World Bank estimated that the Indian economy will grow at 5.4% in FY2022 as “the rebound from a low base is offset by muted private investment growth given financial sector weaknesses”.
